Southern Tomato Pie: A Beloved Southern Classic

If you’ve never tried Southern Tomato Pie, you’re missing out on one of the most iconic and delicious comfort dishes of the American South. With its flaky crust, juicy summer tomatoes, rich cheese blend, and creamy mayonnaise filling, this pie delivers a burst of savory-sweet flavor in every bite. It’s the epitome of what Southern cooking is all about—simple ingredients elevated with heart and heritage.

Rooted in the coastal kitchens of the Carolinas and Georgia, this dish is often enjoyed during peak tomato season, when gardens are overflowing with ripe, sun-warmed fruit. You’ll find it on tables from family reunions to potlucks, served as a main dish or a side alongside grilled meats. This flavorful pie has a story to tell—of family, tradition, and the enduring appeal of Southern summer recipes.

For those unfamiliar with tomato varieties or new to gardening, the Old Farmer’s Almanac offers a helpful guide on choosing the right tomato varieties to use for your dish. And if you’re curious about the deeper traditions behind this dish, the Southern Foodways Alliance provides valuable insights into the culture and history of Southern food traditions.

The Roots of Southern Tomato Pie

The history of Southern Tomato Pie is debated among food historians, but most agree that it emerged as a way to make use of excess garden tomatoes in the summer. The earliest recipes can be traced back to Southern cookbooks from the early 20th century, where the dish was noted for its economical use of fresh produce, pantry staples, and dairy.

Traditionally associated with South Carolina and surrounding states, it became a seasonal favorite—especially in rural areas where tomatoes were grown in abundance. Over time, it evolved, with families adding personal touches like crumbled bacon, caramelized onions, or spicy herbs. But the soul of the dish remains unchanged: a celebration of summer’s bounty encased in a golden crust.

What Makes It “Southern”?

There are several elements that define this dish as unmistakably Southern:

• Use of fresh, ripe tomatoes—preferably local or heirloom varieties
• Binding mixture of mayonnaise and cheese (yes, mayo!)
• A flaky, buttery pie crust as the base
• Seasonings like basil, oregano, and black pepper
• Often served warm or room temperature for a soft, comforting texture

These features combine to create a dish that balances savory, sweet, creamy, and tangy—everything you want in a comfort food.

Core Ingredients You’ll Need

To craft the perfect Southern Tomato Pie, gather these key ingredients:

• Tomatoes (beefsteak, heirloom, or Roma work best)
• Shredded cheese (sharp cheddar is most traditional, but mozzarella and Parmesan are great add-ons)
• Mayonnaise (Hellmann’s or Duke’s are Southern favorites)
• Onions (preferably sweet onions like Vidalia)
• Basil or Italian seasoning
• Bacon (optional, but highly recommended)
• Pie crust (homemade or high-quality store-bought)
• Salt, pepper, and garlic powder for seasoning

Choosing and Preparing the Crust

Your crust matters. A soggy bottom can ruin the whole experience. Here are some tips:

• Blind bake your crust at 350°F for 8–10 minutes to avoid sogginess
• Prick the bottom with a fork before baking
• Let it cool before adding the filling

If you’re going for a healthier twist, a whole wheat or gluten-free crust can work, though you might sacrifice a bit of that classic buttery taste.

Tomato Prep: Avoiding the Soggy Pie Pitfall

The juiciness of tomatoes is both a blessing and a challenge. To avoid a watery pie:

• Slice tomatoes about ½-inch thick
• Lay them on paper towels
• Sprinkle with salt and let them drain for at least 30 minutes
• Pat dry before layering

These steps remove excess moisture while concentrating the natural tomato flavor.

Step-by-Step Classic Recipe

Here’s how to build your traditional Southern Tomato Pie:

Ingredients:

• 1 pre-baked pie crust
• 3 large ripe tomatoes, sliced
• ¾ cup mayonnaise
• 1 cup sharp cheddar cheese
• ½ cup Parmesan cheese
• ½ cup chopped sweet onion
• 3 strips crispy bacon, crumbled (optional)
• ¼ tsp each of salt, pepper, and garlic powder

Instructions:

1. Preheat oven to 350°F
2. Layer half of the tomatoes in the pie crust
3. Mix mayo, cheese, onion, bacon, and seasonings
4. Spread half the mixture over tomatoes
5. Repeat with remaining tomatoes and topping
6. Bake for 45–50 minutes until golden and bubbly
7. Let cool slightly before serving

Variations to Try

While the classic is always a hit, try these fun twists:

• Bacon & Cheddar Pie: Amp up the smoky flavor with extra bacon
• Green Tomato Pie: Slightly tart and less juicy—great alternative
• Goat Cheese & Herb Tomato Tart: Lighter and more gourmet
• Crustless Tomato Pie: For a low-carb version, bake it in a casserole dish

The Seasonal Connection

Southern Tomato Pie is more than a recipe—it’s a seasonal ritual. Tomatoes are at their peak in late summer, which makes this dish a celebration of warm weather and backyard gardens. It’s often featured at:

• Family BBQs
• Church potlucks
• Garden parties
• Casual summer lunches

And it pairs beautifully with light sides and grilled entrees.

What to Serve With It

Here are some winning combinations:

• Grilled chicken or pork chops
• A crisp green salad with vinaigrette
• Buttermilk biscuits or cornbread
• Iced tea or a chilled glass of Chardonnay

The pie itself is hearty enough to be a main dish, but flexible enough to serve as a side.

How to Store and Reheat

Tomato Pie stores well if handled correctly:

• Refrigerate leftovers in an airtight container for up to 3 days
• Reheat in the oven at 300°F for 10–15 minutes
• Avoid microwaving—this ruins the texture
• You can freeze it, but expect a slightly softer texture upon thawing

For safe and proper food storage, use the FoodKeeper App to ensure freshness.

Tomato Pie in Southern Culture

Beyond the dinner table, this pie holds a place in Southern food lore. It’s been featured in regional food magazines, local newspapers, and increasingly on social media. TikTok and Instagram have helped bring this humble dish to a new generation of home cooks and food lovers.

Some even liken it to a savory cousin of the sweet fruit pies found at church suppers—proof that tomatoes, like peaches or berries, deserve their moment in a crust.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is Southern Tomato Pie served hot or cold?
Warm or room temp is ideal. Chilling it may affect texture.

2. Can you use green tomatoes?
Yes! They’re firmer and offer a tangy twist.

3. Why is mayo used in this pie?
It acts as a binder and adds creamy, tangy depth.

4. Can I make it vegetarian?
Definitely—just skip the bacon.

5. What’s the difference between Northern and Southern tomato pie?
Northern versions are more like pizza with tomato sauce and cheese. Southern tomato pie is richer and uses mayo.

6. Can I prep it in advance?
Yes—assemble it a few hours ahead and refrigerate before baking.

7. Can I freeze tomato pie?
You can, but the texture may become softer.

8. What herbs go well with it?
Fresh basil is a classic, but thyme, oregano, and chives work too.

9. Is a homemade crust better?
Usually, yes—but a quality store-bought crust can work in a pinch.

10. How long does it take to bake?
About 45–50 minutes at 350°F.

Southern Tomato Pie is a true testament to the power of simplicity in cooking. With just a few garden-fresh ingredients and a bit of love, you get a dish that tells a story—one filled with flavor, tradition, and the unmistakable warmth of Southern hospitality.

Print